iphone - How does Apple know you are using private API?

Question

I submitted a binary file to Apple without any source code.

Apart from manually checking the source code how does Apple know what was used and what APIs you have called?

Answer 1

There are 3 ways I know. These are just some speculation, since I do not work in the Apple review team.

1. otool -L

This will list all libraries the app has linked to. Something clearly you should not use, like IOKit and WebKit can be detected by this.

2. nm -u

This will list all linked symbols. This can detect

• Undocumented C functions such as _UIImageWithName;
• Objective-C classes such as UIProgressHUD
• Ivars such as UITouch._phase (which could be the cause of rejection of Three20-based apps last few months.)

3. Listing Objective-C selectors, or strings

Objective-C selectors are stored in a special region of the binary, and therefore Apple could extract the content from there, and check if you've used some undocumented Objective-C methods, such as -[UIDevice setOrientation:].

Since selectors are independent from the class you're messaging, even if your custom class defines -setOrientation: irrelevant to UIDevice, there will be a possibility of being rejected.

---

You could use Erica Sadun's APIKit to detect potential rejection due to (false alarms of) private APIs.

---

(If you really really really really want to workaround these checks, you could use runtime features such as

• dlopen, dlsym
• objc_getClass, sel_registerName, objc_msgSend
• -valueForKey:; object_getInstanceVariable, object_getIvar, etc.

to get those private libraries, classes, methods and ivars. )