c++ - How do I remove code duplication between similar const and non-const member functions?

Question

Let's say I have the following class X where I want to return access to an internal member:

class Z
{
    // details
};

class X
{
    std::vector<Z> vecZ;

public:
    Z& Z(size_t index)
    {
        // massive amounts of code for validating index

        Z& ret = vecZ[index];

        // even more code for determining that the Z instance
        // at index is *exactly* the right sort of Z (a process
        // which involves calculating leap years in which
        // religious holidays fall on Tuesdays for
        // the next thousand years or so)

        return ret;
    }
    const Z& Z(size_t index) const
    {
        // identical to non-const X::Z(), except printed in
        // a lighter shade of gray since
        // we're running low on toner by this point
    }
};

The two member functions X::Z() and X::Z() const have identical code inside the braces. This is duplicate code and can cause maintenance problems for long functions with complex logic.

Is there a way to avoid this code duplication?

Answer 1

For a detailed explanation, please see the heading "Avoid Duplication in const and Non-const Member Function," on p. 23, in Item 3 "Use const whenever possible," in Effective C++, 3d ed by Scott Meyers, ISBN-13: 9780321334879.

Here's Meyers' solution (simplified):

struct C {
  const char & get() const {
    return c;
  }
  char & get() {
    return const_cast<char &>(static_cast<const C &>(*this).get());
  }
  char c;
};

The two casts and function call may be ugly, but it's correct in a non-const method as that implies the object was not const to begin with. (Meyers has a thorough discussion of this.)